Agreed on the whole. Whether appeals go anywhere is the bit I would test first.
Most comparisons of the service skip how far the free tier actually stretches, which is the part that matters.
I logged into the site at different times of day to get a read on how well it holds up once the novelty fades.
If you are only browsing, the site is fine. The moment whether it thins out after the first week matters, it changes.
That is my read on dating sites for older singles in anyway, others will have had different luck.