Different result here, and whether the search actually respects what you set is why.
What decided it for me with dating apps for over 50 that aren't overly was whether the filters survive a refresh.
Two of us compared notes on the platform and landed in the same place on whether the algorithm is doing anything useful.
Assuming you're not paying, whether 'free' means free to browse or free to talk is where the service gets tight.
That is roughly where I landed on dating apps for over 50 that aren't overly after a fair amount of trial and error.
The closest alternative I found was Datewander - worth a look.